AESOP AI Academy

Panel Scoring Dashboard

◆ How AESOP Was Scored
Enter Scores — One Column Per Reviewer
Claude
Narrative Integrity
Gemini
Technical Accuracy
Perplexity
Real-World Alignment
Panel
Composite Avg
1 — Narrative Integrity
/ 25
/ 25
/ 25
avg
Story Creates the Problem
×2 weight → max 10
/ 5
/ 5
/ 5
—avg
Learner Lands the Insight
max 5
/ 5
/ 5
/ 5
—avg
Narrative Density Match
max 5
/ 5
/ 5
/ 5
—avg
Character Consistency
max 5
/ 5
/ 5
/ 5
—avg
D1 Subtotal
—
—
—
—
2 — Concept Accuracy
/ 20
/ 20
/ 20
avg
Definition Accuracy
×2 weight → max 10
/ 5
/ 5
/ 5
—avg
Real-World Case Fidelity
max 5 (Advanced only)
/ 5
/ 5
/ 5
—avg
Misconception Prevention
max 5
/ 5
/ 5
/ 5
—avg
D2 Subtotal
—
—
—
—
3 — Level Appropriateness
/ 20
/ 20
/ 20
avg
Vocabulary Calibration
max 5
/ 5
/ 5
/ 5
—avg
Cognitive Framing
×2 weight → max 10
/ 5
/ 5
/ 5
—avg
Subset Integrity
max 5
/ 5
/ 5
/ 5
—avg
D3 Subtotal
—
—
—
—
4 — Delivery Architecture
/ 15
/ 15
/ 15
avg
Learner Orientation
max 5
/ 5
/ 5
/ 5
—avg
Pacing Support
max 5
/ 5
/ 5
/ 5
—avg
Story-Concept Flow
max 5
/ 5
/ 5
/ 5
—avg
D4 Subtotal
—
—
—
—
5 — Applied Outcome ⬆ HIGHEST PRIORITY
/ 20
/ 20
/ 20
/ 20
avg
Lab Executability
×2 weight → max 10
/ 5
/ 5
/ 5
—avg
Quiz Tests Judgment
max 5
/ 5
/ 5
/ 5
—avg
Clear Capability Delta
max 5
/ 5
/ 5
/ 5
—avg
D5 Subtotal
—
—
—
—
Total Score / 100
—
—
—
—
—
D5 Override Check
—
—
—
—
—
Panel Composite Verdict
—
Panel Average Score
—
Score Range (Low–High)
—
Panel D5 Average
Reviewer Notes

Claude

Gemini

Perplexity

85–100 = Pass
70–84 = Pass with Notes
55–69 = Revise & Resubmit
0–54 = Rebuild
D5 < 8 = Override (cannot pass)